LIFESTYLE
Texas Roadhouse Still Sent Sirloin After a Filet Order
Texas Roadhouse confirmed one Forsyth sirloin after a $29.99 filet order, then said its plate check made three misses nearly impossible.
Texas Roadhouse confirmed a Forsyth, Illinois, diner received a $19.49 sirloin after ordering a $29.99 Dallas Filet, then said three such misses would be nearly impossible. Kenneth Card posted the claim on Oct. 5, 2026, after what he described as three visits to the same steakhouse.
The chain’s annual report tells investors a manager inspects every plate before it leaves the kitchen. That rule is now the company’s proof that Card’s other two visits could not have happened, and the reason one confirmed miss still stings.
The Forsyth Menu Prices a $10.50 Gap
The Forsyth location lists an 8-ounce Dallas Filet at $29.99, with two sides. The same menu prices an 8-ounce hand-cut sirloin at $19.49. That is a $10.50 spread on the same plate size, before tax and tip.
The Dallas Filet is sold as the chain’s most tender steak, lean, and a cut that melts in the mouth. The sirloin is sold as lean, juicy, and a value steak. Both are 8-ounce dinners. Both come off the same grill line, under the same seasoning, on the same metal plate.
FILET AND SIRLOIN AT FORSYTH
| Cut | 8-ounce price | Menu pitch | Muscle |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dallas Filet | $29.99 | Most tender, melts in the mouth | Tenderloin |
| Hand-cut sirloin | $19.49 | Lean, juicy, priced as a value | Rear sirloin |
Card ordered the filet. He says the plate that arrived chewed like the cheaper steak. On a high-volume grill, that $10.50 is the whole argument, because the sides, the rolls, and the ticket look the same either way.
He Cut Steaks for a Decade Before He Filmed One
Card is not a first-timer guessing at a menu photo. He told interviewers he has worked in kitchens for most of his adult life and has cut steaks in two professional kitchens, including a steakhouse, for more than a decade. In the video he named ribeye, filet, T-bone, and New York strip as cuts he can tell apart.
He said a filet melts in the mouth and is very tender, while sirloin is a little grittier and a little chewier. That is a cook’s test, not a lighting test. He also said he had been a regular at the Forsyth restaurant for nearly three and a half years with no steak trouble before the first wrong plate. In the video he said he had been coming about once a week for the last year.
When I go into a place, and I order a $30 steak, I expect to eat a $30 steak.
Kenneth Card, diner, Forsyth, Illinois
He sent the first wrong steak back and got a filet as a replacement. He ate the second one. On the third visit he asked for a manager, waited for a new filet, and took it to go. Then he posted the warning, with on-screen text that read “Texas Roadhouse shame on you.” The clip passed more than 34,000 views.
Every Plate Is Supposed to Get a Manager Check
Texas Roadhouse built its name on steaks cut in the restaurant, not on a factory line. The 2025 annual report filed with the SEC says each domestic location has a trained meat cutter who hand-cuts the steaks, and that almost every steak is cut daily on the premises and cooked to order over open grills.
The same filing is blunter about what happens after the grill. The company says it expects a management-level employee to inspect every entrée before it leaves the kitchen, matching the ticket for the order, quality, portion, look, and presentation. Product coaches exist to keep kitchens on recipe and portion. That inspect-every-plate line is not a slogan on a wall. It is how the company describes the business to shareholders.
We expect a management level employee to inspect every entrée before it leaves the kitchen to confirm it matches the guest’s order and meets our standards for quality, portion size, appearance, and presentation.
Texas Roadhouse, Inc., 2025 annual report, U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
Integrity sits in the published core values beside passion, partnership, and fun with purpose. When a $10.50 cut leaves under the wrong name, the filing and the plate are in a fight. A manager glance is fast. A tenderloin and a sirloin are not the same shape on a board. After heat, butter, and seasoning, they get closer. The check is supposed to catch that anyway.
Staff Took the Sirloin Back for a Second Look
Card’s third visit is the one with witnesses in the dining room. He told the server he thought he had the wrong steak. The server took the plate for a second opinion and came back, he said, confirming it was sirloin. He then asked for a manager and said this was the third time the restaurant had tried to sell him a sirloin, or some other cut, as a filet.
According to Card, the manager looked at him as if he were stupid or crazy and said a mix-up was impossible because a manager in the back already approves every plate. That is the annual-report rule, spoken at the table. Card said the manager then had no answer when the current plate was the wrong cut. He waited for a replacement filet, boxed it, and went home to film.
He said he made the video so other diners would check the meat they paid for. He also said he is done with that location and does not want anything from the company. He had not been contacted by Texas Roadhouse when he sat for interviews in late October.
What Separates an 8-Ounce Filet From a Sirloin?
Filet mignon is a steak cut from the tenderloin, a long muscle along the spine that does almost no work on a live animal. Guides that compare the two cuts treat the tenderloin as the most tender muscle on the carcass, with a fine grain and little connective tissue. Top sirloin comes from farther back, where the muscle works harder. It is lean, wider, and chewier at the same doneness.
An 8-ounce filet usually sits taller and rounder, a compact medallion. An 8-ounce sirloin spreads wider and flatter and often shows a clearer grain or a thin fat strip. Cooking hides some of that. A dark crust, a ladle of butter, and a crowded plate can fool a diner who only looks. They are less likely to fool someone who has broken down both muscles for a living, because the chew does not lie.
TELLS ON THE PLATE
- Shape: Filet is a tall, round medallion; sirloin is wider and flatter at the same weight.
- Chew: Filet gives almost no fight; sirloin stays firmer and a little gritty even at the same temperature.
- Grain: Tenderloin is fine and tight; sirloin shows a coarser fiber once you cut it.
- The catch for kitchens: After a hard sear, those visual gaps shrink, which is why the manager check is supposed to happen before the plate walks.
Card’s complaint is that the cheaper chew kept showing up on the dearer ticket. If he is right on all three visits, the miss is at expo, not in the meat room. The cutter already separated tenderloin from sirloin. Someone still put the wrong steak on the filet ticket.
Texas Roadhouse Confirmed One Mix-Up at Forsyth
A spokesperson said on Oct. 26 that the company had looked into Card’s video and had not been able to track that the swap occurred on three occasions. Management, the spokesperson said, quickly made it right on the visit it could confirm, by giving Card the filet he had ordered. Team members, the chain said, double-check food for quality and accuracy as it is expedited from the kitchen. Guests who get the wrong item, or a wrong charge, should tell a server at the time.
On Oct. 28 the company went further. It said an extensive investigation had found no other customer complaints about incorrect steaks at the Forsyth location, and that repeated errors would be nearly impossible under those quality-check processes.
One of our core values is integrity, and while we are disappointed that this guest received the sirloin in error, this is not something that is an ongoing issue.
Texas Roadhouse spokesperson, company statement
WHAT WE KNOW
- One miss logged: The chain says this guest received a sirloin in error and that the team replaced it with the filet he ordered.
- The price gap: The Forsyth menu puts the 8-ounce Dallas Filet at $29.99 and the 8-ounce sirloin at $19.49.
- The written rule: The annual report expects a manager to inspect every entrée against the ticket before it leaves the kitchen.
WHAT IS UNCONFIRMED
- Three visits: Card says it happened three times; the company says it cannot track the other two.
- Other stores: Commenters on the video described similar plates at other locations; those claims are anecdotal and sit outside the Forsyth complaint log.
- The manager’s words: The “impossible” line comes from Card’s account of the third visit, not from a company transcript.
That split is built into the check itself. A glance at expo does not create a record unless a plate is sent back and remade. Card ate the second steak. There is nothing for a later review to pull. The visit that produced a replacement is the visit the chain can see. Calling three misses nearly impossible follows from a process that only writes down the miss it already fixed.
Other diners describing the same swap does not prove a plot across the system. It does show why a quality check that lives in a manager’s eye leaves a quiet kitchen looking clean. People who never send a steak back never enter the log the investigation later cites.
The Chain Now Runs 755 Steakhouse Restaurants
W. Kent Taylor opened the first Texas Roadhouse in Clarksville, Indiana, in 1993. As of June 30, 2026, the company and its franchisees operated 755 Texas Roadhouse restaurants in 49 states, one U.S. territory, and ten foreign countries. Hand-cut steaks, free rolls, and a manager on the pass are how that chain still describes itself.
Card has not heard from the company and says he does not want a payout. He also says he will not go back. The annual report still tells investors a manager will look at every plate. One of those plates, the chain now says, was a sirloin on a filet ticket.
-
NEWS3 months agoMicrosoft 365 Auth Fault Took Down Exchange and Teams
-
GAMING3 months agoXbox Caps Game Pass Cloud Gaming at 15 Hours
-
NEWS3 months agoOpenClaw 2.0 Ships a Team Workplace With Host-Trust Defaults
-
NEWS3 months agoOpenAI Unveils GPT-6 Astra With a Critical Cyber Label
-
LIFESTYLE3 months agoSquishy Dumpling Toys Recalled After Hiding Illegal Water Beads
-
BUSINESS3 months agoDiesel Breaks Its Record as the White House Claims Credit
-
NEWS3 months agoIFA 2026’s Weird Gadgets Are Building a Sensor Home
-
BUSINESS3 months agoChargePoint Stock Rally Prices Wilmer’s Three-Year Cash Plan
