NEWS
Most Merging Black Holes May Form Without a Supernova
A Caltech fit finds 76% of merging black holes piled at 10 solar masses, a quiet-collapse pattern, not a rare failed supernova freak.
A Caltech-led fit to 153 LIGO, Virgo, and KAGRA mergers puts 76 percent of binary black holes in a spike at 10 solar masses. That is the typical hole the detectors hear, not a freak.
Isaac Legred, Jacob Golomb, and Katerina Chatziioannou report the result in Physical Review D, published November 10, 2026. They argue the pile-up, and a near-empty stretch just above it, matches black holes born when stars collapsed without a supernova.
Three-Quarters of the Sample Pile Up at 10 Solar Masses
Chatziioannou, a Caltech physics professor and LIGO team member, said a vast majority of merging black holes are about 10 times the mass of the Sun. “Our data are showing that this group of black holes may have a common origin. They may be a distinct subpopulation that failed to go supernova,” she said.
The published model uses 153 events from GWTC-4.0. The fraction of binaries with a primary in the failed-supernova peak is 0.76, with a 90 percent region from 59 percent to 83 percent. Caltech’s account of a later 257-event sample, the GWTC-5.0 check, still puts three-quarters of that set at 10 solar masses. The conclusions persist in that newer catalog, the paper says.
The network of LIGO in Louisiana and Washington, Virgo in Italy, and KAGRA in Japan has now spotted more than 300 black hole collisions, Caltech said, starting from the first detection in 2015. The new work does not catch a star in the act. It finds hints of a distinct population whose masses and spins look like quiet implosions.
THE 10-SOLAR-MASS PILE-UP
| Primary mass | Merger-rate picture | What the fit assigns |
|---|---|---|
| About 10 solar masses | Peak density 7.36 (plus 6.35, minus 3.11) per solar mass per year per cubic gigaparsec | 76% of the binaries, 59% to 83% at 90% |
| 12.0 to 16.1 solar masses | Rate consistent with zero at 90% credibility | The dip between the peak and the next group |
| Above about 16 solar masses | Rate rises to nonzero, then falls at higher mass | A separate high-mass population |
The paper records a peak rate density of 7.36 in those units at 10 solar masses. From about 10 to about 15 solar masses the rate drops by about two orders of magnitude, a collapse across a few suns, not a gentle slope.
Why 14-Solar-Mass Black Holes Barely Show Up
Legred, now a postdoc at the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign who did the work at Caltech, put the puzzle in one line. “We see 10 solar-mass black holes merging all the time,” he said. “But why are, say, 14 solar-mass black holes so rare?”
Between 12.0 and 16.1 solar masses the merger rate is consistent with zero at 90 percent credibility, then climbs again above about 16. If one smooth power law made every stellar black hole, that empty strip would be hard to keep. The authors let the 10-solar-mass group be its own truncated Gaussian, cut off from the heavier binaries, and the data like that split.
They are careful. Earlier flexible models did not find a clean gap in primary mass, and this fit prefers a gap without requiring one. Compact stellar cores can pile some holes near 9 to 10 solar masses, but population-synthesis work cited in the paper boosts that rate by only a factor of about 3. The observed drop is far larger. Something else has to pinch off black-hole birth in a narrow mass window.
Stars of 12 to 14 Suns Skip the Explosion
The extra pinch, in this reading, is a failed supernova. Core-collapse theory already allows some stars to implode when the shock never launches. Among solar-metallicity models the paper leans on, that failure clusters in a thin birth-mass band.
HOW THE QUIET CHANNEL PILES UP AT 10 SUNS
- Compact cores: Carbon-oxygen cores near 6.5 solar masses run anomalously compact, which makes a successful explosion harder and a direct collapse easier.
- A thin birth band: Simulations of dying stars find stars of 12 to 14 solar masses prone to fail, and in some runs only objects near 12 solar masses refuse to explode.
- Neighbors go bang: Stars just lighter or heavier still explode, shed almost all their mass, and leave neutron stars or much lighter holes, so they do not refill the 10-solar-mass bin.
- Binaries that survive: Direct collapse should impart weaker kicks than a neutrino-driven blast, so more pairs stay bound and later merge in the LIGO band.
Those 12-to-14-sun stars, once they collapse, reliably leave holes around 10 solar masses. The heavier merging population is treated as a different power-law group that only turns on near 16 solar masses. Mix the two, and you get a spike, a dip, and a recovery, which is the shape in the catalog.
Golomb, who did the work in Chatziioannou’s lab and is now at Asari AI, is the third author. Funding came from the National Science Foundation, the U.S. Department of Energy, and the Simons Foundation. LIGO is operated by Caltech and MIT.
The Red Supergiant That Vanished From Hubble’s Frame
Optical searches have been hunting the same deaths for years, and they are almost designed to miss them. A failed supernova can look like a star that was there and then was not. The best-known case is N6946-BH1, a 25 solar mass star that vanished in the spiral NGC 6946, 22 million light-years away.
That object is not the 12-to-14-sun channel in the new fit. It is a heavier red supergiant, a different part of the failed-supernova map, and still a candidate rather than a closed case. It is the picture everyone reaches for because telescopes actually watched a star go dark.
THE DISAPPEARANCE OF N6946-BH1
- 2007: Hubble records the 25 solar mass red supergiant in visible and near-infrared light.
- 2009: The star brightens to more than 1 million times the Sun’s luminosity for several months, then fades.
- 2015: Hubble no longer sees the star. Faint infrared light remains, possibly debris falling toward a new hole.
- May 25, 2017: NASA and Ohio State report the disappearance as a likely failed supernova, after Large Binocular Telescope, Hubble, and Spitzer checks come up empty.
Christopher Kochanek, professor of astronomy at Ohio State, said massive fails of this kind could explain why the most massive stars so rarely show up as supernovas. Scott Adams, who did the survey work as an Ohio State student, counted one likely failed supernova against six ordinary supernovas in the first seven years of monitoring, a ratio that suggested 10 to 30 percent of massive stars die this way. Kochanek put the upper end at as many as 30 percent.
The typical view is that a star can form a black hole only after it goes supernova. If a star can fall short of a supernova and still make a black hole, that would help to explain why we don’t see supernovae from the most massive stars.
Christopher Kochanek, professor of astronomy, Ohio State University, NASA Hubble release
Krzysztof Stanek, also at Ohio State, already tied that silence to LIGO in 2017. He suspected it is much easier to make a very massive black hole if there is no supernova to blow the envelope away. A later vanishing-star analysis by R. Forés-Toribio and Kochanek names a second promising candidate in Andromeda, M31-2014-DS1, beside N6946-BH1. Nobody has a confirmed failed supernova. The graves are easier to count in gravitational waves than in a dark patch of sky.
Pair-Instability Leaves a Desert at Much Higher Mass
The 12.0 to 16.1 dip is easy to confuse with a different, older gap. Pair-instability supernovas, in which oxygen-core photons spawn electron-positron pairs and unbind the star, are predicted to forbid black holes from about 50 to 130 solar masses. That desert sits far above the 10-solar-mass spike. It is a separate argument, with its own fights over where the lower edge sits in GWTC-4 data.
TWO GAPS, TWO PHYSICS STORIES
| Feature | Low-mass dip in this paper | Pair-instability desert |
|---|---|---|
| Mass window | 12.0 to 16.1 solar masses, rate consistent with zero at 90% | About 50 to 130 solar masses in classic stellar models |
| Proposed cause | Failed supernovas from 12-to-14-sun stars, plus a high-mass power law that turns on near 16 | Stars fully disrupted by pair-instability blasts, leaving no remnant |
| What sits next to it | A 10-solar-mass peak holding 76% of merging binaries | Heavier holes, including possible second-generation mergers that refill the gap |
Mixing the two gaps would make the new result look like a textbook reprint. It is not. The Caltech team is talking about the cheap, common end of the LIGO mass scale, the holes that dominate the catalog, and asking why the next few solar masses go missing.
Low Spins and a Dark Patch of Sky
Mass is not the only fingerprint. The 10-solar-mass group occupies a narrower range of spin rates than the full sample, Caltech said, and binaries in this mass range already tend toward low spins in earlier catalog work. A shared, slow spin distribution is what you expect if one collapse recipe made most of them.
That is still a population argument. The authors did not find a failed supernova. They found that the gravitational-wave catalog is consistent with most binary black holes forming from a very special kind of one.
WHAT WE KNOW
- The peak: Primary masses pile up at 10 solar masses in GWTC-4.0, with a rate density of 7.36 (plus 6.35, minus 3.11) in the paper’s units.
- The empty strip: From 12.0 to 16.1 solar masses the rate is consistent with zero at 90 percent credibility, then recovers above about 16.
- The share: 76% of the binaries, 59% to 83% at 90 percent, sit in the failed-supernova peak component of the model.
- The optical record: N6946-BH1, a 25 solar mass star 22 million light-years away, went dark between Hubble frames in 2007 and 2015 after a 2009 outburst.
WHAT IS UNCONFIRMED
- Direct collapse: No failed supernova has been confirmed, including N6946-BH1 and M31-2014-DS1.
- A hard gap: The new fit prefers a gap in primary mass but does not require one, and earlier flexible models did not claim one.
- The engine: Compactness alone, in the synthesis calculations the authors cite, cannot produce a drop of two orders of magnitude.
Syndication of the Caltech note leaned on the word rare. That word fits 14-solar-mass holes. It does not fit a component that can hold 76 percent of the mergers. The sharper limit is the one Legred already named: you can stare at historical images of massive stars, but the objects of interest vanish and leave a dark patch of sky.
With this study, we show the gravitational-wave data are consistent with most binary black holes forming from a very special kind of failed supernova, but more research is needed.
Isaac Legred, lead author, Caltech statement on Physical Review D 114, 103023
Future Catalogs Will Stress-Test the Quiet-Collapse Gap
GWTC-5.0, the collaboration’s next public inventory, already adds detections through January 28, 2025, and brings the total to 390 transients in the cumulative catalog with a probability of astrophysical origin of at least 0.5. The new slice from the second part of the fourth run is 161 compact-binary candidates, all consistent with binary black holes in the events with detailed masses, ranging from 5.14 to 70 solar masses. The quiet-collapse peak has to survive that larger pile, and the next one after it.
If the 12.0 to 16.1 strip stays empty as the sample grows, the case for a separate low-mass channel gets harder to wave away as a modeling choice. If events start to land in the dip, the failed-supernova Gaussian was doing too much work. Either way the detectors are counting remnants that telescopes were built to miss.
The 10-solar-mass holes were never a side population in this catalog. They were the main peak, waiting for someone to ask why the next few solar masses did not show up.
-
NEWS3 months agoMicrosoft 365 Auth Fault Took Down Exchange and Teams
-
GAMING3 months agoXbox Caps Game Pass Cloud Gaming at 15 Hours
-
NEWS3 months agoOpenClaw 2.0 Ships a Team Workplace With Host-Trust Defaults
-
NEWS3 months agoOpenAI Unveils GPT-6 Astra With a Critical Cyber Label
-
LIFESTYLE3 months agoSquishy Dumpling Toys Recalled After Hiding Illegal Water Beads
-
BUSINESS3 months agoDiesel Breaks Its Record as the White House Claims Credit
-
NEWS3 months agoIFA 2026’s Weird Gadgets Are Building a Sensor Home
-
BUSINESS3 months agoChargePoint Stock Rally Prices Wilmer’s Three-Year Cash Plan
