Connect with us

BUSINESS

Halloween’s Record Spend Hides a Smaller Candy Haul

Candy prices are up 7.7%, but the $13.5 billion Halloween record sits in costumes and décor as shoppers take home fewer sweets.

Published

on

U.S. candy and gum prices rose 7.7% in the year through September, more than twice the 3.7% increase in overall consumer prices. The National Retail Federation still projects a record Halloween. Costumes and decorations now take more of that money than the sweets almost every celebrating household still plans to buy.

Almost everyone still intends to put candy in a bowl. Scanner data through mid-October show those households are taking home fewer pieces, and less chocolate, than a year earlier.

$4.4 Billion Goes to Costumes, $4.1 Billion to Candy

The federation’s survey of 7,889 consumers, taken Sept. 1-9 with a margin of error of 1.1 percentage points, puts Halloween spending to reach $13.5 billion, up from $13.1 billion in 2025. Per-person spending is $115.14, or $0.69 more than last year’s $114.45. Seventy-four percent of consumers plan to celebrate, compared with 73% last year and 68% in 2019.

Candy remains the most common purchase, with 96% of those consumers planning to buy sweets. It is no longer the biggest check. Costumes are projected at $4.4 billion and decorations at $4.3 billion. Candy is projected at $4.1 billion. Greeting cards, a smaller bucket, are expected to total $0.8 billion, with planned purchases up to 42% from 38%.

WHERE THE $13.5 BILLION GOES

Category Share planning to buy Projected spend
Costumes 71% $4.4 billion
Decorations 78% $4.3 billion
Candy 96% $4.1 billion
Greeting cards 42% $0.8 billion

Those four lines do not add to the headline total, and they are not meant to. They are the main planned buckets in a holiday that also includes pet outfits and a long list of extras. The ranking is the point: the item almost everyone buys is the one that no longer leads the bill.

Handing out candy is still the top activity, at 61%, ahead of dressing up at 50%. Decorating, carving pumpkins and watching scary movies each sit at 42%. Shoppers have stretched the season. Forty-nine percent say they began buying in September or earlier, up from 34% in 2016. Discount stores remain the top stop at 39%, followed by specialty costume shops at 32% and online at 27%. Local stores are on 13% of lists, nearly double 7% a decade ago.

Allison Zeller, the federation’s vice president of industry and consumer insights, said consumers “continue to make Halloween a spending priority, but they are also approaching the season with affordability in mind.” If prices run hotter than expected, 31% say they will comparison shop, 26% will look for coupons or sales, and 34% will hunt for items they can reuse.

Why This Year’s Chocolate Still Carries Last Year’s Beans

Cocoa futures have already broken. New York prices hovered around $5,400 a tonne on Oct. 30, after a record above $12,000 a tonne in December 2024, but the chocolate on Halloween shelves was contracted against last year’s expensive beans, so the 7.7% jump in candy and gum prices still hits the checkout before any harvest rebound does.

The Bureau of Labor Statistics’ candy and chewing gum price index is up 7.7% from September 2025 to September 2026. That is more than 18% above its level two years earlier. Over the same 12 months, overall consumer prices rose 3.7%. Food prices rose 2.5%, and food at home, the grocery basket, rose 1.8%. Candy is running far ahead of the rest of the cart.

David Branch, sector manager at the Wells Fargo Agri-Food Institute, said the cocoa in the chocolate candy on shelves now was purchased in 2025. Last year’s bean prices were high. Global production has since improved, and Branch called retail chocolate prices sticky: they do not fall as soon as cocoa does, because of the lag between buying beans and filling bags.

THE COCOA CLOCK BEHIND THE BAG

  1. December 2024: New York cocoa futures hit a record above $12,000 a tonne after poor West African crops.
  2. 2024/25 season: The International Cocoa Organization’s indicator price averaged $6,612 a tonne, 39% above the prior season.
  3. 2025: Candy makers lock in beans that later show up in Halloween 2026 chocolate.
  4. 2025/26 season: Broker StoneX puts the global surplus at 494,000 tonnes, enough to rebuild stocks.
  5. Oct. 30, 2026: Futures hover around $5,400 a tonne, with ICE warehouse stocks at a 2.5-year high.

StoneX has already flagged a swing the other way for 2026/27, a 64,000-tonne deficit if El Niño cuts West African output. That is a problem for later holidays. It does not change the beans already inside this year’s bars. Sugar and fuel have stayed expensive too, which gives manufacturers another reason to hold the line at the register.

Fewer Pieces at a Higher Price Per Bag

The federation’s $4.1 billion candy figure is what people say they will spend. What they have actually scanned through mid-October is smaller. Consumer Edge Basketview data on chocolate sales through Oct. 15 show dollar sales down 2.3% from a year earlier, volume down 7.1%, and the average price per unit up 5.2%.

Non-chocolate candy is weaker still. Dollar sales are down 9.2%, volume down 10.6%, and unit prices up only 1.6%. Gummies and sours were supposed to catch the households walking away from chocolate. In this October window, they did not.

OCTOBER CANDY, FIRST TWO WEEKS

Category Dollar sales Volume Unit price
Chocolate -2.3% -7.1% +5.2%
Non-chocolate candy -9.2% -10.6% +1.6%

Figures are October month-to-date through Oct. 15, from Consumer Edge Basketview. Versus 2023, chocolate dollars are about flat and volume is still down 7.0%, with unit prices up 7.7%. The three-year read is the same story in slower motion: households pay more and take home less.

NielsenIQ, looking at a slightly different clock, found Halloween candy sales down 6.7% in the month ending Oct. 17, after an 11.7% drop in mid-September that wiped out the early-season gains of the prior two years. Halloween chocolate sales fell $33.1 million in the nine weeks ending Oct. 17, the largest drop in at least three years, and milk chocolate accounted for the decline. White chocolate was flat. Dark chocolate was slightly higher.

The day of Halloween and the day before have historically run about 1.5 to 2.0 times a typical October candy day, so late filling of bowls can still change the month. It cannot rewrite the price. Chris Costagli of NielsenIQ noted that non-chocolate Halloween candy averaged $6.08 a pound in those nine weeks, about 3% cheaper than a year earlier, and demand still did not jump.

Hershey Raised Its Profit Outlook as Halloween Softened

The Hershey Company reported third-quarter results on Oct. 29. Net sales came in at $3.28 billion. The company narrowed organic sales growth for the year to about 3% and raised its earnings outlook, pointing to lower cocoa costs and tariff refunds. U.S. convenience-store sales of candy, gum and mint fell nearly 5% in September, a slide that ran into October. Hershey is not planning broad price cuts. It is leaning on promotions and different pack sizes.

Halloween participation is expected to be in line with 2025, though financial pressures could shape final purchase decisions.

Kirk Tanner, chief executive, The Hershey Company, Oct. 29 earnings call

Tanner told analysts the last days before Halloween matter, and that large trick-or-treat packs work in Hershey’s favor if households show up. Participation matching 2025 is not the same as matching 2025’s baskets. A household can still dress a child, light the porch and buy a smaller bag.

That split is already visible in last year’s mix. Circana found chocolate still led Halloween candy, but its share slipped from 55% to 51% as cocoa prices pushed shoppers toward non-chocolate. The firm expects more of that shift this year, even as this October’s scanners show the whole candy run shrinking.

Tariffs Catch Small Chocolatiers Mid-Season

Cocoa is the famous input. It is not the only one. Branch also pointed to sugar, fuel and U.S. tariffs on imports. The federation’s own follow-up found that 79% expect tariffs to lift prices on Halloween goods this year. For a national brand that hedges cocoa as far as two years out, those extra costs are a margin problem it can often pass along. For a small maker buying wrappers on a shorter clock, they are a planning problem.

Enna Grazier, who owns the New Hampshire small-batch company Enna Chocolate, said a 50% tariff hit some of the holiday packaging and ingredients she had planned to buy from Canadian suppliers.

I’ve had to look elsewhere or get creative with some of my packaging needs for this holiday season, and that’s super frustrating. It’s meant that I can’t plan as far out, or the plans that I did make were disrupted and we’ve had to pivot and change.

Enna Grazier, owner, Enna Chocolate

THE COST STACK UNDER THE WRAPPER

  • Last year’s cocoa: Beans bought in 2025 still sit inside this Halloween’s chocolate, after the 2024/25 price spike.
  • Sugar and fuel: Other factory inputs stayed high even after cocoa futures fell by more than half from the peak.
  • Canadian packaging: A 50% Section 338 duty on selected Canadian goods raised the cost of some wrappers and ingredients for U.S. makers.
  • The Oct. 30 swap: A proclamation signed Oct. 23 took 22 Canadian product lines off that 50% list, including some packing materials, and added 100 others, including certain cocoa powder, effective 12:01 a.m. Eastern on Oct. 30.

The last-minute list change lands on Halloween’s eve. It may ease some box and bag costs going forward. It does not refund the Canadian packaging Grazier already had to replace, and it newly taxes some cocoa powder just as bean prices were the one input finally moving the right way.

Gummies, White Creme and the Smaller Bag

Large candy companies have been rewriting recipes around the expensive part of the bar. KitKat’s marshmallow-flavored Witch’s Brew and Reese’s White Ghosts, coated in white creme, are this season’s examples of products that do not lean on the same cocoa bill as a standard milk-chocolate bar. More gummy and sour lines have filled the same end caps.

Shoppers have a parallel move: buy less, in a smaller pack, closer to the night. NielsenIQ found small-pack dollar sales up 24% in the Halloween window, while every larger size declined. Sally Lyons Wyatt, global executive vice president and chief adviser for consumer goods at Circana, has been tracking no-sugar, low-sugar and less-sugar candy, plus trick-or-treat-size popcorn cakes, yogurt-coated snacks, bars and ready-to-eat popcorn. Those items are growing. They are also a way to fill a bowl without paying milk-chocolate prices.

HOW THE BAG IS CHANGING

  • Smaller packs: The only Halloween bag size growing in dollars is the small one, up 24%, while large and extra-large bags fall.
  • Less cocoa in the recipe: Marshmallow KitKat and white-creme Reese’s Ghosts keep the brand on the shelf without a full milk-chocolate pour.
  • Non-chocolate fillers: Gummies, sours, popcorn and yogurt-coated snacks take space in the bowl as chocolate’s Halloween share slips.
  • Later trips: Lyons Wyatt said households have been making smaller, more frequent grocery runs and buying closer to when they will use the product, which can make mid-October look weaker than the night itself.

“I do believe we will still see softness overall with candy, but I don’t think Halloween is doomed,” Lyons Wyatt said. Softness and a live holiday can sit together. A record spend on costumes and yard décor does not require a record chocolate dump on the stoop.

The Porch Bowl Gets Lighter Even as the Holiday Grows

On Oct. 31 the federation’s survey is already in the books, and the last shopping day is the one Tanner called. Households that refuse a $30 assortment box are not leaving the holiday. They are filling bowls from dollar stores, handing out something other than candy, or buying the small bag that still shows a 24% dollar gain. One recurring complaint in public posts this week is the big variety pack that now sits near the price of a restaurant meal, while an $8 dollar-store bag still exists for anyone willing to change brands.

That is the second bill, after the 7.7% CPI tag. Halloween 2026 is a larger costume-and-décor season with a thinner candy run. The cocoa market already staged its collapse. The beans in the fun-size bars did not. Kids still walk. The chocolate they get was paid for last year, at last year’s price, in a smaller handful than the record spend implies.

Harry is the editor of BUDGY APP, an independent title he owns and runs after ten years in journalism that began on a reporter's desk and ended up at the editor's. Numbers get particular attention here. A percentage in a business story is recomputed from the underlying figures before it goes live, a benchmark in a technology or gaming review is quoted with the conditions it was measured under, and a transfer fee or a lap time in the sports and auto pages is traced back to the club, the league or the timing sheet that published it. The same rule covers news, science, entertainment, lifestyle and travel: if a figure cannot be tied to a filing, a dataset, a transcript or a test Harry ran himself, it does not appear. Readers around the world see prices in the original currency with a conversion alongside. Errors are corrected in the open under a published corrections policy, with the change noted on the article. Questions about any figure reach him at support@budgyapp.com.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Trending