Connect with us

BUSINESS

Weil Gotshal Calls Outside Counsel After Its Merger Dies

Weil leaders met all Sunday and called restructuring counsel after Willkie talks died, Ramona Nee refused the top job, and more than 40 partners left.

Published

on

Weil, Gotshal & Manges leaders sat through Sunday, Oct. 25 without a break, then picked the conversation back up on Monday, after merger talks with Willkie Farr & Gallagher had already died and the partner named to run the firm refused the job. One leader had already called outside restructuring counsel for a map of the options.

That is the same firm whose own site still sells a bankruptcy practice as the gold standard, built on Lehman Brothers, General Motors, and chief debtors counsel in 6 of 10 historic filings. The people who used to write the rescue plan are now asking someone else to write one for them.

Weil Spent Sunday Mapping Options After Willkie Walked

The management committee met uninterrupted for the whole of Sunday and came back Monday, people familiar with the matter said. Several of its own members are already leaving for rivals, so the group in the room is smaller than the one that started the year.

Willkie talks ended Thursday night, Oct. 22, after the two firms had signed a nondisclosure agreement. A combination was described as a new top-five U.S. firm with more than $4 billion in annual revenue. Hours before those talks stopped, some Weil partners were still being asked to get excited about a deal.

On Tuesday, Oct. 20, leadership had pulled the whole partnership onto a virtual call, asked people to stay calm and keep work moving, and had some of them sign nondisclosure agreements. In September the firm had said it was not in merger discussions with any firm. By mid-October it was, and a web address combining the two names had been registered. Skadden, Linklaters, and Cleary each denied talks of their own. Vinson & Elkins was also named as a possible partner. Willkie was the one that got as far as paper.

WHAT WE KNOW

  • The Sunday session: The management committee met all day Oct. 25 and resumed on Oct. 26.
  • The failed combination: Willkie talks ended the night of Oct. 22 after a nondisclosure agreement had been signed.
  • The refused job: Ramona Nee told colleagues over that weekend she will not become executive partner in January 2027.
  • The outside call: One leader recently asked restructuring counsel for guidance on options.

WHAT IS UNCONFIRMED

  • A filing: No bankruptcy petition, dissolution vote, or lender default has been made public.
  • Nee’s next seat: Talks with Simpson Thacher & Bartlett have been described by people familiar with them; Weil said she has not interviewed and does not have an offer.
  • Wolf’s calendar: It is unclear whether Executive Partner Barry Wolf still plans to step away on the old timetable.
  • Another merger: Other firms were approached; none has been named as a live deal.

Calling restructuring counsel does not mean a chapter 11 petition is coming. It does mean the partnership is being advised the way Weil has advised companies whose capital structure, leadership, and talent base were all in motion at once.

More Than 40 Partners Walked Out

The Willkie collapse did not create the hole in the partnership. More than 40 partners had already left, or announced they were leaving, in 2026, across New York, Washington, Boston, and London. Corporate, private equity, funds, finance, and securities litigation all lost names that had been on the management committee or in department chairs.

Michael Aiello, the corporate chair, took a six-partner M&A group to Cravath, Swaine & Moore, a move Weil described as a jump to “a smaller platform.” Simpson Thacher and Paul, Weiss, Rifkind, Wharton & Garrison have since treated the remainder, including the bankruptcy group and the Boston office, as open recruiting ground.

WHERE THE NAMES WENT

Partner Role at Weil Destination
Michael Aiello Corporate chair, management committee Cravath (six-partner M&A team)
Drew Tulumello Appellate, management committee Davis Polk
Chantale Fiebig Litigation, management committee Davis Polk
Caroline Zalka Securities litigation, management committee Paul Weiss
Lyuba Goltser Corporate co-managing partner Sidley Austin
Christopher Machera Private equity co-head Paul Weiss
Tom Richards London finance head Simpson Thacher
David Avery-Gee London M&A leader Sullivan & Cromwell
Michael Hickey Former corporate co-managing partner Sullivan & Cromwell

A three-partner London restructuring team went to Akin. Seventeen London partners have left since January. Simpson Thacher had already taken private equity and funds names including Murray Cox, Simon Saitowitz, Stephanie Epstein Srulowitz, Brian Parness, and Andrew Nichol. The exits are not a single practice blowing up. They are the people who could move a client relationship in one phone call.

Weil has not been only on the losing side of the lateral market. The firm said in September it had taken more than 50 lateral partners since the start of 2025, and it elected 17 new partners effective Jan. 1, 2026. Debra Sinclair came back to the restructuring group from Willkie, the seventh former Weil lawyer to return in 2026. Peter Feist came back from Cravath as U.S. co-head of private equity. Those hires did not stop the names in the table from leaving.

The Practice That Saved GM Is Now a Recruiting Target

Weil still runs one of the largest dedicated restructuring benches in the business, more than 140 lawyers, and it still books the work that built the brand. Through the third quarter of 2026 the group had advised on more than $55 billion of liability-management transactions. On Oct. 21 the firm posted top rankings in the Octus EMEA restructuring tables. On Oct. 16 it collected four honors at the IFLR Americas awards.

In January it was named one of only four U.S. firms honored as a 2025 Bankruptcy Group of the Year, on the back of First Brands Group, a restructuring with more than $12 billion in liabilities, and Steward Health Care’s $9.2 billion chapter 11. Matt Barr, now global chair of restructuring, and Jeffrey Saferstein, a U.S. co-chair, were the names on that run of cases.

THE BENCH THAT IS STILL BUSY

  • Historic docket: Weil has been chief debtors’ counsel in 6 of the 10 largest U.S. bankruptcy filings, a list that includes Lehman, General Motors, and Washington Mutual.
  • Headcount: More than 140 lawyers sit in the global restructuring group.
  • Recent volume: More than $55 billion of liability-management work through the third quarter of 2026.
  • Live matters: The firm’s own list still includes WeWork, Serta Simmons Bedding, Core Scientific, Cano Health, and Scandinavian Airlines.

Saferstein, talking about getting Steward’s plan confirmed, did not sound like a lawyer on a fading island.

You’re talking about patients and hospitals. Life and death.

Jeffrey Saferstein, U.S. Restructuring Co-Chair, on the Steward Health Care chapter 11

That is the practice Simpson Thacher and Paul Weiss started calling after the Willkie talks died, along with Boston, which is Nee’s home office. The asset Weil can still put on a pitch book is the asset other firms now want to peel off. A three-partner London restructuring team has already gone. Loyalty is a hard sell when the other side of the table pays more and the home platform is in a leadership search with no announced end date.

In July, Wolf made Barr global chair of restructuring and said the practice sat at the center of how the firm planned to grow. Nee, still introduced then as the next executive partner, backed the same bet. Ten weeks later the corporate chair was gone. Twelve weeks later the heir was gone too.

A Successor Who Declined the Chair

Nee, co-managing partner, co-head of U.S. private equity, and co-managing partner in Boston, joined Weil in 2001 and built a sponsor practice around names such as Advent International. In March she was named to succeed Wolf as executive partner on January 2027, the first woman chosen for that job. Wolf has led the firm for about 16 years, since the years just after the 2008 financial crisis, and had planned to stay on as chair of the management committee through the end of 2027 to hand the seat over in stages.

In May, sitting with her for an interview, he put the succession in personal terms.

Nothing would make me happier or prouder than her leading this firm to even greater heights.

Barry Wolf, Executive Partner, in a May interview

On Sept. 25, announcing Feist’s return, Nee was still speaking as the incoming leader, and she used the language of a firm that intended to buy its way through a rough patch, citing tremendous ambitions for Weil and a plan to keep investing in people. Over the weekend of Oct. 25 she told the leadership committee she would not take the job. Weil said she has not interviewed with other firms and does not have an offer. People familiar with the matter have described conversations with Simpson Thacher, which has already hired a string of Weil private equity and funds partners. Those conversations could still fall apart. A sizable share of the Boston partnership would be expected to follow her if she did leave, according to one person close to the office.

THE SUCCESSION THAT LASTED SEVEN MONTHS

  1. March 2026: Nee is named executive partner, to start in January 2027, with Wolf staying as management-committee chair through the end of 2027.
  2. July 15, 2026: Barr is made global chair of restructuring. Nee speaks as the next executive partner.
  3. Sept. 11, 2026: Aiello’s six-partner M&A team is bound for Cravath.
  4. Sept. 24-25, 2026: Sinclair and Feist return. Nee is still on the letterhead as incoming leader.
  5. Oct. 20, 2026: An all-partner call asks the room to stay quiet and keep working while merger talks run.
  6. Oct. 22, 2026: Willkie talks end Thursday night.
  7. Oct. 25, 2026: Nee tells colleagues she will not take the job. The management committee meets all day.

The three-person leadership group had been Wolf, Nee, and Managing Partner Jonathon Soler. With Nee out of the succession, it is not public who would sit in the executive partner chair if Wolf still leaves, or whether he now stays. A firm that spent 2026 advertising a clean handoff now has an open job, a smaller management committee, and a recruiting story that writes itself for every rival on the list above.

Weil Gotshal Profits Trail Davis Polk and Paul Weiss

Weil’s last published year still looks rich on paper. The firm took in $2.077 billion of revenue and $5.593 million of profits per equity partner. That PEP figure sits well above the Am Law 100 average of $3.59 million for the same year. It also sits well below the firms that are hiring its partners. Weil’s revenue was roughly flat in a year when the 100 largest U.S. firms as a group grew revenue 13 percent.

Senior partners have pointed to pay, and to the lack of a long-term plan they believed, as the reasons people left. The table is the plan the lateral market already priced.

PROFITS PER EQUITY PARTNER, LAST PUBLISHED YEAR

Firm Profits per equity partner
Davis Polk $9.800 million
Paul Weiss $8.631 million
Simpson Thacher $8.569 million
Weil Gotshal $5.593 million
Am Law 100 average $3.59 million

A partner who can move a book does not need a sermon about culture when Davis Polk, Paul Weiss, and Simpson Thacher are all millions of dollars a year higher on the same ranking. Weil is still a highly profitable firm. It is not in the pay band of the firms stripping it. That gap, not a single failed merger, is what turned a succession into a recruiting cycle. Older partners who will not shrink their share of a flat pie, and a market that has spent a decade copying a more mercenary staffing model, produce the same result: the people who floated the ship leave, and the people who remain are asked to wait for a combination that may not come.

The Dewey Lesson Partners Already Know

Lawyers of a certain age do not need a chart to remember Dewey & LeBoeuf. The 2007 combination of Dewey Ballantine and LeBoeuf, Lamb, Greene & MacRae was supposed to create a global platform. It created a stack of multiyear pay promises the firm could not keep, then a partner run. By early May 2012 Dewey had lost 90 of its 300 partners. About 160 fled that year. The firm filed for bankruptcy that May with about 1,040 lawyers, 26 offices, $225 million of debt, and $315 million of claims sitting with creditors.

A later study of that diaspora, drawn from employment records rather than war stories, found that 80 percent of Dewey partners landed as partners or senior counsel at other Am Law 100 firms. Associates had a harder first year. The people with portable clients walked into new letterheads. The people without them scrambled.

HOW A PARTNER RUN ACTUALLY WORKS

  • The first movers: Rainmakers leave while the brand still helps them get a better seat, taking clients with them.
  • The failed rescue: Leadership shops a merger, then watches the other firm back away once the leaks start.
  • The leftover ledger: Pay promises, leases, and bank lines stay with whoever is last in the room.
  • The split outcome: Most partners land. Staff and many associates do not move on the same terms.

Weil is not Dewey on the public numbers that exist today. There is no disclosed $225 million credit hole, no announced criminal inquiry of a chairman, no memo telling partners to find new jobs. Weil’s restructuring group is still being hired on billion-dollar cases. Those differences matter, and they are why a filing is unconfirmed. The sequence that is already on the page, a rainmaker drain, a merger that dies in public, a succession that collapses, and a call to restructuring counsel, is the sequence partners in this market have watched before.

Hospital Cases Still Need a Firm on the Letterhead

Chapter 11 work does not freeze because the debtor’s law firm is having a leadership fight. Steward’s hospital docket, First Brands, WeWork, Serta, and the rest of the list on Weil’s own restructuring page still need people who can walk into a courtroom next week. If Simpson Thacher and Paul Weiss keep pulling at that group, the question for those clients is not who wins a trade-press item. It is whether the team that started the case is the team that finishes it.

Associates, staff, and the partners who cannot pick up a book and leave are the ones who sit through the next all-hands call. They are also the ones Dewey’s record treated most roughly in the first year after a collapse. Weil has not said it is dissolving, and it is still hiring, still posting awards, still putting Barr’s group on new liability-management deals. It is also a firm whose designated leader handed the job back before she sat down, whose merger partner walked away, and whose management committee spent Sunday asking an outside restructuring lawyer what the options look like from here.

The next move belongs to the people still in that room, and to the clients who have to decide whether the letterhead on last month’s retention papers is the letterhead they want on the next one.

Harry is the editor of BUDGY APP, an independent title he owns and runs after ten years in journalism that began on a reporter's desk and ended up at the editor's. Numbers get particular attention here. A percentage in a business story is recomputed from the underlying figures before it goes live, a benchmark in a technology or gaming review is quoted with the conditions it was measured under, and a transfer fee or a lap time in the sports and auto pages is traced back to the club, the league or the timing sheet that published it. The same rule covers news, science, entertainment, lifestyle and travel: if a figure cannot be tied to a filing, a dataset, a transcript or a test Harry ran himself, it does not appear. Readers around the world see prices in the original currency with a conversion alongside. Errors are corrected in the open under a published corrections policy, with the change noted on the article. Questions about any figure reach him at support@budgyapp.com.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Trending